The Wilson Beacon

A history of DC statehood and taxation without representation

Back to Article
Back to Article

A history of DC statehood and taxation without representation

Alex Metzger

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






On July 2, 1767, the British parliament passed the Townshend Acts, enabling England to freely tax all goods coming to the North American colonies, without the colonies having a stake in the British government. This shift in the colonists’ way of life was introduced with the help of British troops authorized to be a sort of armed IRS.

When America’s founders had the opportunity to design their country after the Revolutionary War, they knew that taxes were necessary to build a strong and healthy society, and that the only way to tax justly was by giving citizens government representation. So how did DC lose the battle for representation in government? Why is Eleanor Holmes Norton, DC’s delegate to the House of Representatives, more of a notetaker than a true delegate?

When the Founding Fathers created DC with intent for it to be the nation’s capital, they did not foresee that it would become a region with a population of around 700,000 or intend for citizens to establish permanent residence in it. DC didn’t even have a city government until 45 years ago, and Congress still retains the right to abolish the city government and govern the District themselves.

Many people today argue that one of the modern reasons for DC’s lack of statehood is political motive. The District is safely blue, and with such a heavy concentration of Democrats, giving fair representation to its citizens would drastically change the balance of power in Congress, which worries Republicans.

But Republicans don’t have much to worry about, as it would take a constitutional amendment along with a vote to upgrade DC to a state. There are four steps to birth a state in in the U.S. After incredible simplification, it is as follows:

A region becomes a United States territory, then that region becomes an organized territory (a territory with a legislature and territorial governance), then the newly organized territories’ residents have a majority vote on whether they would like to become a state. If they vote yes, then Congress organizes a “constitutional convention” for the aforementioned territorial governance to create legislation. Post legislating, Congress votes on whether or not to admit it to as the 51st state.

The issue with that, however, is that DC is not a territory, since it exists entirely on land donated by the states of Maryland and Virginia. This would involve Article IV Section 3 of the constitution which reads, “no new State shall be formed or erected within the Jurisdiction of any other State; nor any State be formed by the Junction of two or more States, or Parts of States, without the Consent of the Legislatures of the States concerned as well as of the Congress.” So in order for the “DC Statehood” movement to have any form of traction or success, Congress would have to rewrite an entire section of the constitution that deals with statehood.

Giving DC representation in Congress would sway the balance a little too far left for the Republican party’s liking, and to get statehood is a task that is dependent on an incredibly messy constitutional change.

About the Contributors
Alex Metzger, Junior Editor

Alex is a coffee grabber I mean junior editor at the Wilson Beacon. He’s a sophomore who is currently spending his time getting hit below the belt with...

Jackson Fox-Bland, Visual Content Editor

Jackson is a senior human who appreciates pearlescent cacti and sometimes cooks lasagna and hates Mondays.

Leave a Comment

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.




Navigate Left
  • A history of DC statehood and taxation without representation

    Features

    Editors-in-Chief bid farewell

  • A history of DC statehood and taxation without representation

    Features

    Language barriers muffle student voices

  • A history of DC statehood and taxation without representation

    Features

    Beacon Baffler

  • A history of DC statehood and taxation without representation

    Features

    Wilson teachers talk side hustles

  • A history of DC statehood and taxation without representation

    Features

    Mr. Bellino’s Graph of the Month

  • A history of DC statehood and taxation without representation

    Features

    Martin reflects on her time at Wilson

  • A history of DC statehood and taxation without representation

    Features

    What a ride: Dani Moore’s journey to DC

  • A history of DC statehood and taxation without representation

    Features

    Field trips take students to cadaver lab, Supreme Court

  • A history of DC statehood and taxation without representation

    Features

    TigerServe helps students find community service opportunities

  • A history of DC statehood and taxation without representation

    Features

    Students work around internet block

  • A history of DC statehood and taxation without representation

    Features

    How difficult are APs at Wilson?

  • A history of DC statehood and taxation without representation

    Features

    Mythbusting rumored pizza-mob connections in Adams Morgan

  • A history of DC statehood and taxation without representation

    Features

    SoundCloud Artists of Wilson

  • A history of DC statehood and taxation without representation

    Features

    It’s all relative: life as a staff member’s kid

  • A history of DC statehood and taxation without representation

    Features

    Wilson YouTube usage: not clickbait

  • A history of DC statehood and taxation without representation

    Features

    DC teens explore local job market

  • A history of DC statehood and taxation without representation

    Features

    Fruit of the Month

  • A history of DC statehood and taxation without representation

    Features

    Seniors reflect on dual enrollment experience

  • A history of DC statehood and taxation without representation

    Features

    Carrie Thomas: The Tenley barista who doesn’t like coffee

  • A history of DC statehood and taxation without representation

    Features

    Teachers confront cheating at Wilson

Navigate Right
The Student News Site of Woodrow Wilson Senior High School
A history of DC statehood and taxation without representation